Previous readings and assignments
Readings for Tuesday 22 April:
- "Elizabethan Astrological Medicine" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
- "The Character of the Enlightenment" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
- "Astrology after 1650" (pp. 302--309, 338--351) in HM 13 Part 2 packet
-
Voltaire on astrology
Readings for Thursday 24 April:
Short project due Monday 28 April, 5:00 PM
Topic: Demonstrate the astronomical, mathematical,
and astrological practices that an astrologer had to master
by casting a chart for a particular event (a nativity is
most typical, but you can also do an interrogation or
election) at a particular
time and place of your choosing (see outline of
example).
Find the planetary positions
for that time and place (using an ephemeris or an
interactive planetarium and doing any necessary
coordinate conversions); then calculate the position of
the ascendant, determine the houses (according to the
"equal house method"), and identify the characteristics of
that configuration. Create a predictive interpretation of the
chart using the principles in the Tetrabiblos.
Readings for Tuesday 29 April:
- "Astrology and Statistics: A Challenge" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
- "One Astronomer's Views" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
- "The Mars Effect and the Zelen Test"/"The Zelen Test of the Mars
Effect" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
- "Is There a Mars Effect?" in HM 13 Part 2 packet
-
"The Mars Effect in Retrospect"
-
"Why Astrology Works"
Readings for Thursday 1 May:
Second short paper due by Friday 2 May, 2:00 PM
Topic: Improve your intuitive sense of what
astrological practitioners actually saw, and how it relates
to the geometric models we have been using. The work will
consist of the following steps:
- Select three times of day or night, at least 4 hours apart.
At least two of those times should be when it's dark enough to
see some other celestial bodies besides the sun.
- On three different clear days, observe the sky at each of those three
times. Pick about five important celestial objects (other than the
North Star!) and note their positions at each time (naturally,
fewer will be visible during broad daylight). You may use a
planisphere and almanac or
interactive planetarium
to help you identify some well-known objects if you're unfamiliar with them.
Orient yourself to the directions by finding the North Star.
- At each observation, make roughly quantitative measurements of
each celestial object's position with respect to your local horizon, zenith, and
directions. Use whatever approximate measurement tools work for you;
sighting along a protractor to measure angles, using a homemade
mariner's astrolabe,
holding fingers out at
arm's length, etc. Your results will look something like "Jupiter:
three finger-breadths due south of the zenith", "Moon: thin crescent, about
15 degrees above a point on the horizon 10 degrees south of west", etc.
- Draw the positions of the visible objects at each observation on
one of our well-known
observer's hemisphere pictures;
orient them however is most convenient for you to indicate the positions.
- You now have nine sets of observational measurements and a corresponding
hemisphere picture for each set, representing changes in the sky over time.
Hand them in together with an approximately two-page writeup describing
how these results illustrate the basic "two-sphere" geometric model of a geocentric
universe that we've been using. Include a paragraph or so
critiquing your rough-and-ready observational methods, and suggesting
some improvements that a real (pre-modern) astrologer might make
to get better data.
For the benefit of anyone feeling astronomically insecure, there
will be a brief optional introductory observing session on
Sunday evening (April 6, depending on weather) at 7:15 PM (DST)
in Prospect Terrace Park, at Congdon and Cushing Streets
(a couple blocks down the hill from Smith-Buonanno). Good chance for a
rare sighting of Mercury! (Note added at 7:00 PM Sunday: there's a little
more haze and cloud than I would like, but we're going to try it
out tonight anyway.)
Final paper/project due Thursday 15 May, 12:00 noon
The final paper/project should be approximately equivalent in
effort and substance
to a 15-page research paper, but the student is free to choose
the preferred topic and format (subject to the instructor's
approval). Some possible ideas for individual projects include:
- Design, describe, and build a simple working model of an astrolabe.
- Write a research paper on the history and technique of an
astrological topic that we did not cover in depth, such as the
prorogator, the Lot of Fortune, the "rays", etc.
- Write a research paper on a cross-cultural comparison of a
particular aspect of the relationship between astrology and science
in two different civilizations.
- Find and evaluate a modern physical theory purporting to justify
astrology scientifically, and discuss its implications for the modern role of
science.
- Explore the influence and significance of astrology and science
in a different intellectual genre, e.g., through astrological
iconography in painting
or themes in poetry or fiction.
- Investigate the role of astrology in the late-twentieth-century
"Science Wars" involving scientists and science-studies scholars.