symposium.gif - 4.0 K
dworkin.gif - 7.3 K Bear4.gif - 2.6 K

(The full text of the original Dworkin article is available on-line by clicking HERE).

dworkin6de.gif - 20.5 K Commentators:

Simon Blackburn, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, Posted 11/11/96

Michael Otsuka, University of California, Los Angeles, Posted 12/3/96

Nick Zangwill, University of Glasgow, Posted 12/2/96

Reply: Ronald Dworkin, Oxford and New York University, Posted 4/9/97