Graduate Student Handbook

Egyptology and Assyriology
Graduate Student Handbook

July 2017 Edition

Introduction

The Department of Egyptology and Assyriology at Brown University offers three tracks to the doctorate (PhD): Assyriology, Egyptology, and History of the Exact Sciences in Antiquity. Through the Graduate School’s Open Graduate Education Program the Department also offers a master’s degree (AM) for students concurrently enrolled in a PhD program in another department at Brown.

This document provides program-specific information for graduate students in the Department and is thus intended to complement the Graduate School’s published policies and procedures. For comprehensive information about University-wide policies on matters such as funding, leaves of absence, and the like, students should consult the Graduate School Handbook:

https://www.brown.edu/academics/gradschool/academics/rules-regulations/graduate-school-handbook

Applicants to the PhD program are strongly encouraged to contact the relevant faculty and/or the Director of Graduate Studies. Prospective students should also consult the respective web pages of both the Department and the Graduate School:

Department: https://www.brown.edu/academics/egyptology/

Graduate School: https://www.brown.edu/academics/gradschool/programs/egyptology-and-assyriology

At present the Department does not accept applications to its master’s program from students who are not already enrolled at Brown in a PhD program.

Department Contacts

Department Chair: Prof. John Steele (john_steele@brown.edu)

Director of Graduate Studies (DGS): Prof. Matthew Rutz (matthew_rutz@brown.edu)

Department Manager: A. Catherine Hanni (a_hanni@brown.edu)

Funding for the PhD

Financial support of five years is granted to incoming doctoral students funded through the Graduate School with the expectation that this will be their full support during the entire course of their studies. This funding includes a stipend, tuition and fees remission, and a health-insurance subsidy. The stipend is intended to cover the calendar year, not simply the academic year, and students are therefore expected to work on their research during the summer. When progress towards the degree is considered excellent, students may spend time in the summer on professional development, for instance, on outside research fellowships, archaeological fieldwork, or teaching positions.

The University expects research and writing of the dissertation to be completed by the end of a student’s fifth year in the program, at which point guaranteed University funding ends. For students who require a sixth year of funding and do not receive it from another source (e.g., an external fellowship, the Open Graduate Education Program, University-wide interdisciplinary opportunities, or the Deans Faculty Fellows program), the Department will do its best to provide sixth year funding, although it is not guaranteed in every case. In order to be considered for sixth year funding from the Department or to receive the Department’s support for an application to the Deans Faculty Fellows program or one of the University’s interdisciplinary opportunities, we expect students to have met two milestones:

  1. an advanced draft of one chapter of the dissertation to be submitted to the student’s advisor by the end of the August after the fourth year
  2. one third of the dissertation to be submitted and approved by the student’s advisor by the end of December of the fifth year

Please note that completing these milestones is a minimum requirement for consideration for sixth year funding. If the dissertation has not been completed and accepted within seven years of the time the student first entered the program, the Department may require a second set of comprehensive examinations before the dissertation is finally accepted. As per Graduate School rules, students who have not completed their dissertation within five years of being admitted to candidacy must apply to the Graduate School for an extension of candidacy. Students should be aware that such extensions are not guaranteed.

Students will receive one of the following appointments during each semester that they are funded:

  • Fellowship: An award to enable the student to focus full time on either coursework or writing a dissertation.
  • Teaching Assistantship: The student will be assigned as a teaching assistant (TA) to a particular course to assist the instructor with course preparation, marking papers and exams, facilitating class discussions, conducting tutorials, teaching occasional classes, and holding office hours to work with students.
  • Teaching Fellowship: The student will teach his or her own course.
  • Proctorship: Non-instructional academic employment intended to foster the graduate student’s professional development and/or research interests. The student will be assigned to a defined research, program development, or other task to assist faculty in the Department. Possible proctorships could involve preparing teaching materials, managing ancient artifacts in the University’s collections, assisting in the organization of a conference, and assisting faculty with research or editorial projects.

Advising

On entering the program, students will be assigned a primary advisor in their field of interest. Students are expected to consult their advisors on a regular basis to discuss course selection, research projects or publications, exam preparation, external funding opportunities, and other aspects of academic life and professional development. Students may elect to switch to a different advisor at any time, providing the new advisor is willing to act in that capacity. After the student has completed coursework, it is expected that the chair of the dissertation committee will play the role of primary advisor.

Courses and Service: General Information for PhD students

The University requires 24 credits of graduate enrollment. This is accomplished over the course of six semesters by a combination of coursework and TA-ships. The appropriate courses will be determined by the student in conjunction with the primary advisor, the DGS, and the faculty most relevant to the student’s intended course of study. The three degree tracks (Assyriology, Egyptology, and History of the Exact Sciences in Antiquity) each have their own required courses, some of which may be waived depending on a student’s background and abilities (see below). However, the waiver of specific required courses does not obviate the University’s 24-credit requirement.

For the first year, students are on fellowship and take four courses each semester. During the second through fourth years, the Graduate School requires service in the form of teaching assistant (TA) or teaching fellow assignments or, less commonly, proctorships. Each student will have one such obligation per semester; the appropriate balance and specific assignments will be determined by the faculty in consultation with the DGS. When performing service during their coursework students will take four courses during semesters they act as proctors but three courses during semesters they serve as teaching assistants; this accommodates the 15–18 hours weekly time commitment for TAs defined by the Graduate School. TAs receive one enrollment credit per semester as a TA.

The Department’s policy on students receiving a provisional course grade of Incomplete (INC) is the same as that of the University. Incompletes are strongly discouraged, may only be taken in extraordinary circumstances with prior approval of the professor, and they must be completed expeditiously to avoid being placed on academic warning (see below). The Office of the Registrar sets the following guidelines for the completion of incompletes: Unless an earlier date is specified by the instructor, grades of ‘INC’ must be made up as follows: for Semester I [= Fall], by mid-semester of Semester II; for Semester II [= Spring], by the first day of the following semester.

Inadequate performance in courses, while serving as a TA, teaching fellow or proctor, or on exams can be grounds for being placed on academic warning at the discretion of the faculty of the Department (see below). Students on warning will be given explicit instructions about milestones that must be reached to be returned to normal status. While on warning students are expected to focus exclusively on their University commitments and may not receive departmental funding for conference attendance nor take on outside employment or internships.

PhD Tracks and Course Requirements

The Department currently offers three tracks to the PhD: (1) Assyriology, (2) Egyptology, and (3) History of the Exact Sciences in Antiquity. Minimum course requirements for each track are as follows (courses marked * may be waived on demonstration of existing competency):

(1) Assyriology: six courses reading cuneiform texts (primarily Akkadian, including Introduction to Akkadian* and Intermediate Akkadian*; at least one course in Sumerian; possibly also Hittite and/or Ugaritic), two courses on Near Eastern archaeology/art history, one course on scholarship in the ancient Near East, two courses on the archaeology, history, and/or language of a second culture (which could include Hittite and/or Ugaritic, among others), one research seminar (Archaeologies of Text), and one Reading and Research course.

(2) Egyptology: Middle Egyptian I–II*, Middle Egyptian Hieroglyphic Texts, Late Egyptian*, Ancient Egyptian Religion, Ancient Egyptian Literature, History of Ancient Egypt I–II*, at least one course in the basic material culture of ancient Egypt (or, with the approval of the student’s advisor, an advanced course in Egyptian archaeology), two courses in the history, culture, language or archaeology of the ancient Near East or Mediterranean outside of Egypt, and one Reading and Research course.

(3) History of the Exact Sciences in Antiquity: Historiography of the Exact Sciences, four courses in the student’s primary ancient language*, two courses in a secondary ancient language*, three courses in the history/archaeology/culture of the primary culture, one course in the history/archaeology/culture of a secondary culture, two courses on ancient science/scholarship offered within the Department, two courses in the history of science offered by another department (e.g., History), and one Reading and Research course. At least two of the language courses should involve the reading of scientific texts.

As indicated above, beyond the minimum course requirements students in all three tracks are required to take at least one Reading and Research course. Typically taken in the spring semester of the third year, this course provides an opportunity for advanced students to engage with faculty in a focused way on a topic and/or theme that will contribute directly to the student’s research agenda. For example, students may use the Reading and Research requirement to undertake preliminary research around a possible dissertation topic, to prepare a journal article for submission, or to read broadly and/or deeply in a particular area or areas in preparation for the PhD Qualifying Projects.

Examinations

There are three sets of examinations required of all PhD students in the Department:

1. French and German Reading Exams. These reading exams must be passed no later than 31 July prior to the third year of coursework. They will normally consist of a journal article or selection from a book to be studied overnight, followed by an oral examination by the faculty member who acts as the examiner; it is customary for students to provide the examiner with an outline of the reading (in English) in advance of the oral examination. The exam itself will consist of questions about and discussion of the assigned reading in order to demonstrate the student’s ability to comprehend and critically engage with important scholarship in the field. With the approval of the student’s primary advisor and the DGS, a student may replace one of the French or German reading requirements with another appropriate modern foreign language. A language exam will be waived in the case where the language is the student’s native tongue.

2. Comprehensive Exams. The Comprehensive Exams are normally administered toward the end of the second year of coursework (hence their other common designation “second year exams”) and are intended to demonstrate the student’s knowledge in all aspects of her or his chosen field. In the Fall semester of their second year students will meet with the relevant faculty and the DGS to discuss the timing, subjects, scope, and composition of these exams, which must be agreed upon and confirmed in writing prior to the Reading Period of the same semester. The Comprehensive Exams will be both completed by the student and assessed by the faculty no later than 31 May following the student’s second academic year. Some exams may be take-home essays, others timed written and/or oral exams. All of the Comprehensive Exams must be passed satisfactorily before the student can take the PhD Qualifying Projects. In the case of an unsatisfactory performance, a second examination may be scheduled at the discretion of the faculty. The second examination must be both completed by the student and assessed by the faculty no later than 15 August of the same year. No Comprehensive Exam may be taken more than twice. In the event of a first or second unsatisfactory performance, the student may petition the Department to receive a terminal master’s degree (AM), again at the faculty’s discretion.

3. PhD Qualifying Projects. The PhD Qualifying Projects are normally initiated during the final year of coursework and are intended to demonstrate professional competency. These projects will usually focus on different topics that are all related directly or indirectly to the student’s primary research interests and intended dissertation area. The projects take the following form:

  1. an original scholarly contribution in the form of a journal article
  2. a substantial review of a book in the student’s primary area of interest
  3. the preparation of a course outline and syllabus.

The specific topics, including the book for review and the title and topic of the course for the syllabus, will be decided in conjunction with a committee of at least two and normally three faculty, at least one of whom must be from the Department. The student, prospective readers, and DGS must agree in writing on the precise composition of the projects prior to Reading Period of the Fall semester of the student’s third year. It is not expected that the projects will be completed at the same time, but all three projects must be submitted no later than 31 July after the student’s third academic year. Following the submission of the projects, the committee will confer to make their assessment and communicate whether or not the projects have been judged acceptable; the committee will then set up a discussion with the student to give feedback on the projects and discuss prospects for the student’s dissertation topic. If the readers find any project unacceptable, the student will have until 15 December to resubmit the revised project(s). A student may not formally submit a dissertation proposal for approval until the committee has deemed the Qualifying Projects acceptable. In the event of a first or second unsatisfactory performance on the Qualifying Projects, the student may petition the Department to receive a terminal master’s degree (AM) at the faculty’s discretion.

Research Requirement

In addition to the doctoral dissertation, which is the program’s culminating research requirement, the Department has two research requirements for all PhD students: an academic conference paper and a peer-reviewed journal article. Both requirements are important milestones in a junior scholar’s academic career.

All students are required to present at least one formal conference paper during their time in the program. Possible venues include the annual meetings of the American Oriental Society (AOS), the American Research Center in Egypt (ARCE), the American Schools of Oriental Research (ASOR), an international conference in the student’s field, or a more focused academic conference in the student’s area of research. Be advised that the calls for papers for all conferences circulate quite early and that abstracts are typically due well ahead of the conference itself. Students should consult with their advisors about the best topic and venue for the conference paper.

All students are required to publish at least one peer-reviewed journal article during their time in the program. Students should consult early on with their advisors to determine their best work and most suitable possible venue[s] for publication. Possible scenarios include: publishing a written version of the student’s conference paper; publishing the student’s PhD Qualifying Project (journal article); publishing part of the student’s doctoral dissertation results; publishing a significantly revised version of a research paper from a seminar or Reading and Research course; publishing the results of other independent research that was conducted in a museum, during archaeological fieldwork, or over the summer.

Teaching Requirement

Because Brown’s doctoral programs train graduate students to become educators as well as researchers, teaching is an integral part of graduate education. All doctoral students in the program are required to train as teaching assistants for a minimum of 3 semesters. In consultation with the DGS, this requirement may be fulfilled during any of the years in the program, but it is typically done in years two, three, and four. Although not strictly required, interested students may have the opportunity to serve as teaching fellows who teach either a new course of the student’s design or a course that is already established in the curriculum. Students should be aware of the resources and opportunities at the University to develop skills in teaching, in particular the offerings of the Harriet W. Sheridan Center for Teaching and Learning and its certificate programs:

https://www.brown.edu/about/administration/sheridan-center/

Dissertation Proposal

No more than six weeks following the successful completion of PhD Qualifying Projects, the student will submit a doctoral dissertation proposal prepared in consultation with the advisor and readers. Ordinarily there will be significant overlap between the readers of the proposal and the qualifying projects, though changes or additions may be made in consultation with the DGS. The readers must include a primary advisor from within the Department and at least two additional readers. The student’s proposal should be about 10 pages in length (excluding the catalogue and bibliography) and will include: a working title; the research question and a concise summary of previous research on the intended topic; a statement of the purpose, goals, significance, and originality of the project, with a clear justification of the necessity for the proposed study; a clear presentation of the evidence, methods, and procedure for carrying out the research; a detailed outline of the proposed dissertation with chapter summaries; a detailed project timeline and work plan for research and writing; a catalogue of sources; and a comprehensive bibliography.

The advisor will first assess the proposal and will likely require revisions. Once revisions have been made, the advisor and at least two additional readers will evaluate the revised proposal, offer comments and suggestions (possibly requiring further revisions), and vote on its acceptability. Following a favorable vote, the student is formally admitted to candidacy for the PhD, a status commonly known as ABD (“all but dissertation”). Shortly after the proposal has been accepted, the student will present the proposed project in the Department’s research colloquium series.

The formal dissertation committee will consist of an advisor from within the Department, and at least two additional readers, one of whom must come from outside of the Department, preferably from outside the University. Normally external readers from outside the University are formally added to the dissertation committee after the proposal has already been approved by the program, though in some cases it may be appropriate to involve the external reader earlier in the process. While researching and writing the dissertation the student should expect to meet with the advisor on a fortnightly basis and keep the readers apprised of her/his progress with occasional updates.

Receiving the PhD Degree

When the dissertation committee has approved the completed dissertation, ideally midway through the fifth year, the dissertation defense will be scheduled. The penultimate version of the dissertation must be circulated among the readers at least two weeks prior to the defense. The defense will consist of two parts: a formal public lecture and a closed defense.

The lecture is an opportunity for faculty and students in the Department and wider University to learn about the doctoral candidate’s work on the dissertation. The talk should last approximately 50 minutes plus 10–20 minutes for questions. The presentation should cover the background to the project, an overview of the research itself, and a discussion of the most significant results found in the dissertation. Please note that this talk is not meant to be a celebration of the end of the PhD, an opportunity to express thanks, and the like, all of which has its proper place at Commencement at the end of May. Rather the lecture should be a serious presentation of the dissertation to an interested audience.

The formal defense will be a private meeting between the doctoral candidate and the dissertation committee, which will normally include an external examiner. Typically the defense will last about 2 hours, but there is no fixed duration for the meeting. The main topic of discussion during the defense will be the dissertation itself, but it is normal for there also to be some discussion of the context of the research (e.g., other scholarship on the topic, the relevance of the dissertation to related areas of research, etc.) as well as discussion of the prospects for publishing the student’s research after completing the PhD. At the conclusion of the defense, the dissertation committee will vote on whether to recommend that the Graduate School award the student the PhD on the basis of the dissertation, potentially pending revisions. Following a favorable vote, the student is considered to have achieved the PhD, even though the degree itself may not be awarded for several months after the defense. The Department has no requirements for the format of the dissertation beyond those set by the Graduate School. Filing of the final dissertation is subject to University guidelines; however, a hard copy of the final dissertation must be deposited in the Department as well. The student must also submit a final electronic copy to the DGS.

Students writing dissertations should be aware that the procedures surrounding the defense and filing of the final dissertation always take substantial planning and time to execute:

https://www.brown.edu/academics/gradschool/academics/rules-regulations/dissertation-guidelines

The University has only one graduation per year at the end of May, and final dissertations and all associated paperwork must be filed with the University by 1 May of the year of graduation. In order to realistically meet this goal and to give dissertation readers sufficient time to read and comment on the thesis, a complete and mature draft of the dissertation should be given to all members of the dissertation committee at the beginning of the student’s final semester, typically in February.

Student Progress

Student progress will be evaluated each semester, and the student will be informed of her/his standing through banner and through individual communications with the DGS. banner allows three evaluations: “Good,” “Satisfactory,” and “Warning”. These terms are set by the University and thus require some clarification from the program. Students who perform well in coursework and service (i.e., as TAs, teaching fellows, or proctors) and meet all requirements on time will maintain “Good” status in the program. In fact “Good” status is the program’s expectation for all students, which is to say that the Department regards a “Satisfactory” evaluation as an indicator of unsatisfactory progress and as a sign that the student needs to significantly improve his/her performance. “Warning” status indicates that the faculty have very serious concerns about a student’s progress, which, unless addressed, could lead to the Graduate School withdrawing the student from the program.

Students who take one incomplete in a course at the end of a semester will automatically be given a “Satisfactory” evaluation. In order to return to “Good” status, the incomplete must be rectified within the normal timeframe established by the University (see above). Students may also be given a “Satisfactory” evaluation for marginal but still satisfactory performance on the Comprehensive Exams or PhD Qualifying Projects, for poor or inconsistent performance as a TA, teaching fellow, or proctor, or for insufficient progress in the writing of the dissertation. Students with a “Satisfactory” status may not be eligible for various programs or research funds available through the Department or the University.

Students who have more than one incomplete or who fail to rectify an incomplete will be placed on “Warning”. Other reasons for being placed on “Warning” include but are not limited to unacceptable performance as a TA/teaching fellow/proctor, failing the Comprehensive Exams, producing unsatisfactory PhD Qualifying Projects, or failing to make adequate progress on the doctoral dissertation (proposal, research, writing). Students on “Warning” will be informed in writing of the reasons and given the specific milestones they must achieve within a specified period of time in order to come off “Warning” status. Students who do not achieve those milestones may be withdrawn from the program. While a progression from “Satisfactory” to “Warning” may occur, be aware that a student can move directly from “Good” to “Warning” status for any valid reason. For further details on the timing, procedure, and consequences of “Warning” status, students must consult the Graduate School Handbook.

Progress Reports. The program requires that all students beyond their first year submit a short annual progress report (300–500 words) that summarizes the student’s accomplishments in the areas of research, teaching, and service for the previous academic year and the following summer. This short document should include, for example, a description of summer research activities, reflections on the accomplishments of the previous academic year, and an articulation of specific goals for the coming academic year. Reports should be sent to the DGS and the student’s advisor via email on or before 1 September. This report should serve as a tool to catalyze a conversation between the student and her/his primary advisor about the student’s plans for the coming academic year and beyond.

PhD Program Timeline

Year 1

Fall
  • 4 courses
Spring
  • 4 courses
Summer
  • museum/library research
  • modern language study
  • archaeological fieldwork
  • internship
Funding
  • fellowship

Year 2

Fall
  • 4 courses or 3 courses
  • service obligation
  • set Comprehensive Exams, deadline: end of Reading Period
Spring
  • 4 courses or 3 courses
  • service obligation
  • complete Comprehensive Exams, deadline: 31 May
Summer
  • museum/library research
  • modern language study
  • archaeological fieldwork
  • internship
  • travel for research or conferences
  • complete French and German Reading Exams, deadline: 31 July
  • (complete retake of Comprehensive Exams, deadline: 15 August)
Funding
  • service obligations

Year 3

Fall
  • 4 courses or 3 courses
  • service obligation
  • set PhD Qualifying Projects, deadline: end of Reading Period
Spring
  • 4 courses or 3 courses
  • service obligation
  • work on PhD Qualifying Projects
Summer
  • submit PhD Qualifying Projects, deadline: 31 July
  • work on dissertation proposal and preliminary dissertation research
Funding
  • service obligations

Year 4

Fall
  • approval of dissertation proposal, deadline: 15 September
  • dissertation proposal presentation in Department’s colloquium series
  • service obligation
  • research dissertation
  • begin writing dissertation
  • (resubmit PhD Qualifying Projects, deadline: 15 December)
Spring
  • research/writing dissertation
  • service obligation
  • (submit dissertation proposal following resubmission of PhD Qualifying Projects, deadline: 31 January)
Summer
  • research/writing dissertation
  • to be considered for 6th year funding submit one dissertation chapter, deadline: 31 August
Funding
  • service obligations

Year 5

Fall
  • writing/revising dissertation
  • to be considered for 6th year funding one third of the dissertation submitted and approved, deadline: 31 December
Spring
  • writing/revising dissertation
  • submit a completed draft of the dissertation, deadline: February
  • public presentation of dissertation results, deadline: March
  • dissertation defense, deadline: March
  • file dissertation according to Graduate School guidelines, deadline: 1 May
  • deposit hard/digital copies of the dissertation in the Department
  • degree conferred at Commencement, end of May (Sunday before Memorial Day)
Summer (if Year 6 is needed)
  • writing/revising dissertation
Funding
  • fellowship

Year 6 (if needed)

Fall
  • writing/revising dissertation
  • service obligation
Spring
  • writing/revising dissertation
  • service obligation
  • submit a completed draft of the dissertation, deadline: February
  • public presentation of dissertation results, deadline: March
  • dissertation defense, deadline: March
  • file dissertation according to Graduate School guidelines, deadline: 1 May
  • deposit hard/digital copies of the dissertation in the Department
  • degree conferred at Commencement, end of May (Sunday before Memorial Day)
Funding
  • service obligations

Open Graduate Education Master’s Program

Doctoral students at Brown University who are enrolled in another PhD program may obtain an master’s degree (AM) in Egyptology and Assyriology. This is generally undertaken through the Graduate School’s Open Graduate Education program.

Course requirements: 8 courses, of which at least 3 must be 2000-level graduate seminars taught either in the Department (ASYR, EGYT) or by jointly appointed faculty in archaeology (ARCH). Of the 8 courses, at least 2 must be in either Egyptian or Akkadian language, and at least two must be on the history or archaeology of either Egypt or the ancient Near East. The remaining courses are to be chosen by the student in consultation with the DGS, who must approve all course selections used to fulfill the requirements of the master’s degree.

Capstone project: Students must research and write a 5000-word paper on a topic of their choosing within the area of Egyptology and Assyriology. The aim of the paper is not necessarily to undertake original research, but rather for the student to demonstrate a sufficiently broad knowledge of the field, the ability to identify an appropriate research question, and the ability to find appropriate primary and secondary source material relevant to the topic. The project will be assessed by two faculty members in the Department.

In all matters relating to double counting of courses between AM and PhD programs and related matters, the Department will defer to University-wide policies and/or the policies of the student’s PhD department.

Space in the Department

The Department has a limited number of desks in offices that, conditions permitting, can be temporarily assigned for PhD students to share. Desk assignments for the coming academic year will be made during the summer months and will depend upon the availability of space in the Department. Priority will be given to students writing dissertations and to those students serving as teaching assistants/fellows, but this should not be taken to mean that students are guaranteed dedicated work space in the Department. Students should be aware that the assignment of a desk one year does not guarantee that the student will be assigned a desk in subsequent years.

Overseas Travel

Graduate students travelling overseas on Brown University business (e.g., for conferences, museum research, or fieldwork) are expected to register with the Brown University Global Assistance Program through International SOS. Instructions on how to do this may be found at:

https://www.brown.edu/about/administration/global-engagement/office-global-engagement/planning-your-global-activity

Further information is given in the Graduate School Handbook.