Dissertation Advisor and Committee
The Dissertation Committee
Policy on Advisors Who Have Left Brown
Policy on Emeriti Faculty
Admission to Candidacy
Extension of Candidacy
Conducting Dissertation Research Away from Brown
Conducting Research and Traveling Abroad
Advanced Status (opting-out of Graduate School Support)
Exchange Scholar Program
Submission of Dissertations and Theses
Filing of Dissertations and Policy on Public Access to Dissertations
Deadlines and Extensions
Guidelines for Dissertation Titles
Titles of Books within Dissertation Titles
Super- and Sub-script
The Dissertation Committee
Each program should make clear in its handbook how students go about selecting their dissertation advisors and committees, and set a timetable for doing so. Programs should be structured so that each student always has an advisor; leaving a gap between advice from the DGS and advice from the preliminary examination committee and/or dissertation advisor tends to prolong time to degree and increase attrition.
Chairs and DGSs need to be aware of the advising and mentoring relationships in their graduate programs. Monitoring the progress of each student is the responsibility of the program and not simply that of the faculty advisor. The dissertation chair and the other faculty members of a dissertation committee should meet with the student on a regular basis, and certainly a minimum of once a semester.
Under normal circumstances, when a faculty member leaves, his or her advisees will be required to seek a new advisor. Subject to the approval of the chair of the department, faculty who leave Brown may continue to serve as dissertation or thesis advisors for students whom they were advising at the time of their departure. The program must be mindful of the need to provide students with some on-campus supervision and contact in the cases where a non-resident advisor continues service.
Policy on Emeriti Faculty[i]
Emeriti faculty are a valuable resource for students, programs, and the University. The Graduate School has adopted the following guidelines regarding the role of emeriti faculty:
- Faculty who retire and move into emeritus standing may, at the pleasure of the relevant student(s) and program(s), continue to serve as advisors to students who were under their tutelage at the time of retirement.
- With departmental approval, an emeritus faculty member can serve as a reader on a dissertation provided there are no other emeritus faculty members on that thesis committee.
- With departmental approval, an emeritus faculty member can serve as a co-primary advisor on a dissertation along with a regular member of the faculty. An emeritus faculty member cannot serve as the sole primary advisor on a dissertation.
Admission to doctoral candidacy is a student’s last formal requirement for earning the Ph.D. before the submission of his or her dissertation. To be admitted, the student must have passed all other departmental requirements, usually including courses, language proficiency, and one or more written or oral examinations (prelims). Each program’s handbook should clearly explain what the requirements are, how they may be met, what is the timetable or deadlines for meeting them, and what happens when students fail to meet these requirements upon the first attempt as well as what happens regarding subsequent failed attempts.
Most programs allow a second attempt at all or part of the preliminary exams. The program’s handbook should state clear standards for allowing the exam to be retaken and a reasonable time frame for a second attempt. If the exams are tailored to each student’s specific interests, the scope in each case should be clear to the examiners and the student.
The DGS must notify the Registrar and the Associate Dean of Academic Affairs in writing when a student is admitted to candidacy. The date of admission is printed on the student’s transcript, and the fact that he or she has been admitted is required for general reporting purposes within the University as well as many applications for external funding.
Doctoral students have up to five years after admission into their program to achieve candidacy. Students who do not achieve candidacy by the end of their fifth year will be withdrawn from the Graduate School. Requests for a one-year extension for achieving candidacy may be made to the Graduate School by the DGS in the student’s program.
It is University policy that the dissertation should be completed within five years of achieving candidacy. Nevertheless, students sometimes require more time, and in cases where the faculty believes the student will finish and accepts the reasons for delay, candidacy may be extended. Annually the Graduate School will remind active students whose candidacy is about to expire that they must write to their DGS, explain why they are taking so long, and request an extension if they intend to finish. Extensions of up to an additional two years beyond the five years since achieving candidacy may be granted by the Graduate School; extensions beyond two years require a vote of the Graduate Council.
The DGS must request any extension of candidacy from the Graduate School in writing. Note that the student must also write to justify the extension. Any extension must be to a specific date mentioned in the request.
Conducting Research and Traveling Abroad
Research related activities under any circumstances are subject to a variety of important requirements. When there is an international component, these requirements still apply and there may be additional compliance issues that need to be addressed. Please contact the Director of International Research for more information regarding international research.
Before you travel internationally, the Graduate School and the Office of Insurance and Risk urge you to register your trip information with International SOS. If you are traveling on funds provided by the Graduate School or the University, then you are required to register with International SOS.[ii] The University has contracted with International SOS to provide Brown University travelers with 24 hour worldwide medical and travel assistance, including emergency evacuation. To register your trip information go to the Personal Travel Record link at International SOS. At that site you may need to enter Brown University’s International SOS membership number to enter the site. The membership number is 11BSGC000031. Please note that the International SOS website also provides important safety and health information for international travelers.
Additional travel abroad resources can be found at Brown’s Office of International Programs.
Students who have completed their 24 tuition unit requirement and are away from Brown for either one or two semesters conducting dissertation research are considered full-time students, are charged tuition, and must have health insurance from Brown or provide proof of comparable coverage under another plan.
Students who plan to conduct dissertation research away from Brown during one of their years of guaranteed support from the Graduate School have the following funding options available to them: (1) they may be eligible for a dissertation fellowship based on the recommendation of their department, in which case they use one of their years of guaranteed funding; (2) they may have an external fellowship and apply for supplemental stipend and tuition support from the Graduate School under the incentive program; or (3) they may opt-out of Graduate School funding and “stop their funding clock” for up to two semesters. Students who select to opt-out must communicate their decision to the Graduate School and their DGS in writing. The DGS must then report this decision on the student’s appointment form. The “opt-out option” is only available for students who are away from Brown conducting dissertation research.
Students who are awarded external fellowships and do not opt-out of Graduate School supplemental stipend and tuition support are considered by the Graduate School as funded students and the conditions of the external award incentive policy apply.
Students who chose to opt-out of Graduate School funding for one to two semesters to conduct dissertation research away from Brown, are required to pay tuition and health insurance (or provide proof of comparable coverage), during the semesters they are away from Brown. Advanced students conducting dissertation research away from Brown, who elect to opt-out and stop their funding clock, are eligible to apply for Tuition and Health Insurance Scholarships (see below).
Under terms of the Exchange Scholar Program, the graduate schools of the University of California at Berkeley, Brown, the University of Chicago, Columbia, Cornell, Harvard, MIT, the University of Pennsylvania, Princeton, Stanford and Yale have agreed to admit each others’ students for one year of study, where appropriate, without charging tuition; the student must pay the prevailing tuition for full enrollment at his or her home institution. S/he remains an active student at the home institution while studying as an exchange scholar at the host institution. The host institution will charge for student health services if that is not included as part of tuition; and the student may purchase either school’s student health insurance.
Students who find Brown’s library inadequate for their specialty or who would like to work with a professor at one of the other institutions may benefit from the Exchange Scholar Program. The program has also benefited students whose advisors are spending a sabbatical or have taken a new position at one of the other institutions.
Students with external fellowships can continue that support away from Brown and the possibility exists for a student to hold a TA position at Brown while studying at a proximate university such as Harvard. Other students who are within the 5-year guaranteed funding window will either have to use their year of dissertation fellowship funding (with the approval of the program DGS and the Graduate School) or they may elect to forego stipend support for a year by taking advantage of the deferred funding under the Advanced Student status option.
Application forms for the Exchange Scholar Program are available in the Graduate School and online here.
Filing of Dissertations and Policy on Public Access to Dissertations[iii]
Ph.D. candidates at Brown must file their dissertations electronically. Brown's electronic theses and dissertation (ETD) system was developed by the Graduate School and the University Library
and launched in 2008. The system is designed to collect and archive final dissertation as a text-based PDF file. Electronic dissertations submitted through the ETD will appear in the Library's discovery service and in the Brown digital repository.
In the spirit of the dissemination of new knowledge that is a hallmark of higher education, dissertations will be subject to web searches and unrestricted downloads unless the student requests to opt out that system and have their dissertation unavailable for download outside of
the Brown community. A request to restrict download access to a dissertation has an initial two-year window from the time the degree is conferred. Guidelines associated with restricted dissertation access are:
- The full text version of the dissertation will be available for download only to members of the Brown community.
- Web searches including the citation and abstract of restricted dissertations will continue to be available to the general public.
- After two years the restriction will elapse.
- Restrictions on full text download may be renewed for two-year periods up to a total of ten years from the date of degree conferral. Requests for additional two-year restrictions should be made to the Graduate School.
- Any requests to extend the restriction beyond ten years must go to the Graduate Council for approval.
- In cases where the dissertation is a co-worked piece and there is disagreement between the student and the advisor over whether the dissertation will or will not be available for download outside of the Brown community, the dispute will be brought before the Graduate Council for resolution.
To complete the electronic submission process, doctoral candidates must have successfully defended their dissertation and had it approved by their committee. To use the ETD system, doctoral candidates must possess a valid username and password for accessing Brown’s computer network. If you are unable to create an account in the system, please contact ETD@brown.edu for assistance.
The deadline for submission and approval of a dissertation or thesis in time to receive a degree at Commencement is May 1. An extension of this deadline to May 15 is possible upon written request from the dissertation advisor to the Graduate School (see the Academic Affairs Manager) before April 15.
Registration in semester I allows a student to submit a dissertation or thesis until the start of classes in the spring. Registration in semester II allows a student to submit a dissertation or thesis until the start of classes in the following fall. Extensions of these deadlines for one month into the new semester, e.g. September 5 to October 5, are possible upon written request from the dissertation advisor to the Graduate School Academic Affairs Manager one month before the start of the new semester. If the student does not submit the dissertation or thesis before the extension expires and does not need to be an active student, he or she can be placed on “terminated pending requirements” status.
Guidelines for Dissertation Titles
The dissertation title that appears on the title page that you submit to the Graduate School is the title that will appear on your transcript and on the Commencement Program. Students should follow the title guidelines presented below in preparing the title page of the dissertation. Titles must be prepared in upper and lower case using the capitalization rules presented below.
Taken from The Chicago Manual of Style, Fourteenth Edition, 1993, The University of Chicago Press, sections 7.126-7.131.
The first and last words and all nouns, pronouns, adjectives, verbs, adverbs, and subordinating conjunctions (if, because, as, that, etc.) are capitalized. Articles (a, an, the), coordinating conjunctions (and, but, or, for, nor), and prepositions (during, over, under, through, with, without) regardless of length, are lowercased unless they are the first or last word of the title or subtitle. The to in infinitives is also lowercased. Only acronyms should be set in full capitals.
The subtitle, following a colon, is capitalized the same way as the main title.
For capitalizing hyphenated and open compounds in titles use the following rule: First elements are always capitalized; subsequent elements are capitalized unless they are articles, prepositions, coordinating conjunctions, or such modifiers as flat, sharp, and natural following musical key symbols; second elements attached by hyphens to prefixes are not capitalized unless they are proper nouns or proper adjectives. If a compound (other than one with a hyphenated prefix) comes at the end of the title, its final element, whatever part of speech it may be, is always capitalized. Examples: Twentieth-Century, Up-to-Date, E-flat Concerto, Self-Sustaining
Use the word “and” instead of the ampersand “&” and spell out names of centuries (12th Century becomes Twelfth Century) and other numbers usually spelled out in text. Be sure to include accents or other special marks on letters used in non-English words.
Use the final comma in a list (Disease, Pain, and Sacrifice: Toward a Psychology of Suffering).
Melodrama Unveiled: American Theater and Culture, 1800-1850
The Labour Party in Perspective – and Twelve Years Later
Thought and Letters in Western Europe, A.D. 500-900
Titles and subtitles of published books, pamphlets, proceedings and collections, periodicals, and newspapers are set in italics.
Mathematical or chemical names and formulas that appear in the title should retain any super- or sub-script.