Binding agents: Chemistry and Art course builds connections between the laboratory and the studio

A class taught by chemist Li-Qiong Wang teaches the molecular building blocks of artistic expression and enables students to make some art of their own along the way.

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — For much of human history, the color blue was a relative rarity in artistic expression. It’s essentially absent from prehistoric cave art — and a price tag for blue that was larger than that for gold limited its use for thousands of years more.

The reason boils down to chemistry.

While the pigments and dyes needed to make reds, yellows, greens and browns occur commonly in nature, stable blue pigments are rare. Egyptian blue — the world’s first synthetic pigment — was created in 3100 B.C.E., but blues still weren’t readily available until the 19th century when modern chemistry finally enabled mass-production of new pigments like cobalt and synthetic ultramarine.

The historical significance and complicated chemistry of the color blue have given it a major role in Chemistry and Art, a course offered this semester in Brown’s Department of Chemistry by teaching professor Li-Qiong Wang. The course aims to explore key concepts in chemistry in the context of art and art history. Students study the chemistry of pigments and paints, dyes and stains, pottery and porcelains, as well as gemstones and jewelry. And as they learn the chemical underpinnings of artistic expression, they get to make art objects of their own — often using raw materials they synthesize themselves.

Wang says she hopes the class offers a new way for students to look at both art and chemistry, and more importantly, to get them to reach across both the sciences and the humanities.

“It’s just a very interesting intersection,” Wang said. “We’re not a chemistry class, and we’re not an art class. We’re looking at art, art history and art objects through the chemical lens. What I really want to do is train students how to do interdisciplinary thinking — how to collaborate with and learn from people who have very different backgrounds.”

New activities, new insights

Wang started to develop the class in 2018, with the help of two undergraduate students, Isabella Lovelace and Iris Peng, supported by an Undergraduate Teaching and Research Award (UTRA). Wang knew she wanted a class on chemistry and art, and that she wanted it to have plenty of hands-on projects, but she was open to what those projects might be. So she turned her UTRA students loose to explore possibilities.

“I told them, ‘Don’t look at anything and don’t worry about the literature or what’s already been done,’” Wang said. “Just come up with things on your own.”

The result was a series of novel activities in which students make their own pigment, which is then combined with different binders to make paints. Students create a ceramic glaze using their synthesized pigments, then examine color differences that emerge as a function of glaze firing temperature. In another project, students experiment with cyanotype — a photographic method that uses chemicals combined with ultraviolet light to create blue monochrome prints. They then tone the prints to brown or black to investigate the underlying chemistry of the toning process, comparing it with the chemical principles involved in making iron gall ink.

Those activities are interspersed with guest lectures from people in specialized fields. Leslie Welch, an associate professor of cognitive and psychological sciences at Brown, talks about the neurological underpinnings of human color perception. Ingrid Neuman, a conservator at Rhode Island School of Design (RISD), gives a lecture on art conservation. Technical staff members introduce students to X-ray fluorescence (XRF), X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopies used to analyze chemical compounds found in paintings and other objects.

The development of class activities has led to new scientific insights. In the process of synthesizing malachite, a deep green pigment, the UTRA students discovered that shortening the reaction time creates a polymorph of malachite called georgite. Not only is georgite not green like its more common partner (it’s a soft sky blue), it has a surprising reaction when mixed with different binders to create paints. When mixed with an acrylic binder, the pigment creates a stable blue paint. But something strange happens when the pigment is mixed with linseed oil, another common paint binder.

“When we painted with it, it started out blue,” Wang said. “But two or three days later, the color changed to a deep green.”

After careful research to understand the chemistry behind the color transition, Wang and her UTRA students published their findings in 2022. The research not only provides a linchpin activity for the class, it also underscores the importance that pigment-binder interactions have in art conservation.

A learning experience for all

The conservation angle is of particular interest to Kaitlyn Stanton, a senior at RISD who is one of 15 students taking the class this semester. Stanton is interested in an art conservation career.

“There is a pretty direct connection to conservation in the class,” Stanton said. “There is a unit on conservation, but even things that are not explicitly mentioned in that section have a lot to do with conservation. When you think about chemistry and art, everything sort of has to do with conservation in some sense.”

She’s confident that the experience will give her a leg up in the job market.

“In preparing for internships, it's so valuable to be able to know these hard skills,” Stanton said. “Having pre-program exposure to analysis techniques like X-ray fluorescence will make it so much easier to make that transition from school to professional life.”

But the appeal of the class goes beyond art preservation. As a fourth-year Brown-RISD dual degree student studying neuroscience and printmaking, Cassandra Carrasco said she feels at home having a foot in both the art and science camps.

“I feel like I’m the target demographic for this class,” Carrasco said.

“I had a feeling I would be pretty familiar with the artistic techniques and the art history that we cover, but there’s something new for everyone,” she added. “I was really excited by the chemistry of the pigments and binders. I also knew that the class would incorporate some other materials I'm less familiar with, like ceramics.”

For Sydney Chon, an independent concentrator at Brown studying medical humanities, the class has brought abstract and arcane concepts and analytical techniques into the real world.

“I've taken a lot of foundational chemistry courses, like general chemistry and organic chemistry, and we've used things like XRF,” Chon said. “But I thought those things were just for the lab. I wasn’t really aware that they had other practical applications. That’s been interesting to see.”

Helping students find a new way of looking at chemistry is not uncommon in the years she’s taught this course, Wang says: “I’ve seen some students who actually struggle in regular chemistry classes, but in this class they better understand some concepts.”

The more art-focused students reap rewards as well.

“I think it's gotten me really excited about chemistry,” Stanton said. “I'm so much more eager to learn about organic chemistry now that I have this introduction that is based in the material world, and not just all conceptual.”

Most of all, Stanton says, she’s enjoyed interacting with people who come from profoundly different backgrounds.

“A lot of people taking this class are concentrating in STEM fields like biomedical engineering, neuroscience, or chemical engineering. Because there's so much group work, you're not just learning from the lectures and readings, but also from your peers who have very strong chemistry backgrounds,” Stanton said. “I'm interested in learning more.”

That interaction is exactly what Wang had in mind when she created the class. Because as every chemist knows, bringing different elements together in just the right way can often make sparks fly.