From left, fourth-year medical student Fernando Ibanhes, patient J.D. Crooks and Associate Professor of Medicine Dr. Philip Chan discuss patient care during a visit to Open Door Health Clinic in Providence. The clinic, founded by Chan and fellow Professor of Medicine Dr. Amy Nunn, opened in 2020 to meet the medical needs of Rhode Island's LGBTQ+ community. Photos by Nick Dentamaro/Brown University
At community health clinic in Providence, improving access and care for LGBTQ+ patients
Founded by Brown faculty members Dr. Amy Nunn and Dr. Philip Chan, Open Door Health is lowering barriers to health care by providing culturally congruent LGBTQ+-focused care.
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — If the bright, sprawling mural dedicated to Rhode Island’s queer and trans communities isn’t the first thing to make a visitor to Open Door Health in Providence feel at home, they are sure to feel welcome the second they step inside the clinic’s Central Street building.
“It’s our goal to provide a warm embrace from the beginning,” said Dr. Amy Nunn, a professor of medicine and behavioral and social sciences at Brown University and a founder of the clinic. “We will use their preferred pronouns. Their gender expression and sexual orientation are affirmed. If they speak Spanish, we have providers who also speak Spanish. Those things may sound basic, but they’re really not done at many places.”
Those “basic” practices combined with a goal of improving health equity by connecting patient care with research is what drives the mission of Open Door Health, the first dedicated clinic in Rhode Island to provide culturally congruent primary and sexual health care to members of the state’s LGBTQ+ community.
Nunn launched the clinic with Dr. Philip Chan, a Brown associate professor of medicine and behavioral and social sciences. The two work in HIV prevention and treatment, both separately and as frequent collaborators. Nunn serves as the executive director the Rhode Island Public Health Institute, which founded the clinic. At Open Door Health, Chan serves as the chief medical officer; he is also a medical director at the Rhode Island Department of Health. Operations manager Cassie Sutten Coats has been another instrumental partner in the launch.
“Amy and I have always worked so closely together, because we believed in not just studying critical public health issues but addressing them,” Chan said.
The inspiration for Open Door Health came from Chan’s interactions with patients receiving HIV prevention care. Even though some had primary care physicians, they felt more comfortable visiting other clinics and specialized health centers, where their sexual orientation or gender identities weren’t questioned and providers didn’t judge them for seeking Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP, a single pill taken once daily that prevents HIV infection).
“We heard that again and again and again,” Nunn said. “We knew we wanted to have a safety net program for LGBTQ+ folks.”
According to a 2019 poll, 4.5% of adults in Rhode Island identify as LGBTQ+ — one of the highest percentages in the country — yet until Open Door Health launched in March 2020, the founders say there was no clinic dedicated to their health. To receive the specific care they needed, like affirming sexual health and primary care, Nunn said many of her patients would travel to Boston or avoid the doctor altogether.
Applying research for results
With much of Open Door Health’s practice informed by research Nunn and Chan have conducted, the clinic illustrates how Brown physicians and scientists can turn scholarly insights into solutions that make a direct and positive impact on patients in Rhode Island.
With faculty appointments at Brown’s Warren Alpert Medical School and the School of Public Health, Nunn and Chan aim to emphasize the intersection of clinical care, public health research and education. They are both principal investigators of multiple grants to study HIV prevention, including clinical training and intervention to promote PrEP uptake and HIV testing, and they have led several health promotion programs outside of Open Door Health. Together, they embrace the importance of community partnerships to address health disparities.
Their approach to community care is one that stood out to Fernando Ibanhes, a fourth-year medical student at the Warren Alpert Medical School who worked at the clinic last year.
Since arriving at Brown, Ibanhes has trained under the mentorship of Chan. He became involved with Open Door Health around the time he had to complete a practical component as part of the third year of his combined M.D.-master’s degree program, and it was only natural, he said, to explore opportunities to serve patients at the clinic.
The work closely aligned with Ibanhes’ interests. He had previously worked with LGBTQ+ health in New York City before arriving at Brown, and his collaboration with the clinic allowed him to deliver care to a population that he not only cares passionately about, but also identifies with. He said it’s been an important, formative experience as he decides between the fields of infectious diseases and neurology.
“That was one of the reasons I came to Brown,” Ibanhes said. “As a gay man, as a Latino, as a medical student — I knew I was going to have the openness to be who I am and to find the care I need, and hopefully be able to provide that same care to my community.”
In addition to playing an active role in caring for patients under the supervision of Chan, Ibanhes assisted in community outreach efforts — like their COVID-19 vaccination drive — and designed a new manual to prepare future medical and other health profession students for everything they needed to know about working in tandem with the clinic. He said the detail of the work goes to show how intentional the choices are that make up the clinic’s practices.
“A lot of the patients coming in the door are patients that identify with a minority, and there is just palpable excitement from folks who feel like they’ve found a genuine, caring space,” Ibanhes said. He counts himself as one of them, noting that he too receives care at Open Door Health.
Throughout years of medical and public health practice, Chan and Nunn have learned the importance of being part of the communities they serve — and that success is not often found from the outside looking in.
That was the driving force behind choosing the location of the clinic, which is tucked just off of Broad Street in Providence. To Nunn, it was a no-brainer: The neighborhood, near the edge of Upper South Providence and the city’s West End, has lower-than-average income levels and higher-than-average rates of addiction, HIV, sexually transmitted infections and diabetes — all pressing public health issues that the team behind Open Door Health is trying to solve. And while the clinic’s primary population identifies as LGBTQ+, Nunn emphasized that all are welcome.
“One of the things I’m most proud of is that about 35% of our patients are Latinx, 30% of our patients are straight, and we get a lot of people coming in from the neighborhood,” she said. “I think we’re doing a good job of making everybody feel affirmed and welcome.”
Another crucial element of successful community-based care is the ability to adapt to public health crises. With its initial opening date in March 2020, as the onset of COVID-19 began to lock down communities in Rhode Island and nationally, Open Door Health went through trial by fire. The team opened a COVID-19 tent, where they conducted more than 2,000 tests in 2021 and vaccinated more than 400 individuals. The clinic still offers vaccination and screening services, with options for both rapid and PCR testing.
What we do at Open Door Health is public health in action. It’s policy in action. It’s our research delivered how it’s meant to be.
Associate Professor of Medicine and Chief Medical Officer at Open Door Health
J.D. Crooks, a patient, said he originally learned about Open Door Health from his friend Richie DeFilippo, an activist in the local LGBTQ+ community whose face is included on the mural that adorns the clinic’s outside wall. Crooks started regularly visiting for COVID-related services, but has since expanded his involvement by serving on the clinic’s community advisory board.
“If you need something — anything — they’re here for you,” Crooks said.
As he saw more community members grappling with pandemic-related job loss, Crooks began referring people without a primary care physician or health insurance to Open Door Health, noting that the clinic “finds a way to make it work.”
“We do need the clinic to be sustainable, but we don’t focus on money,” Chan said. “If a person owes us $20, we’re not going to turn them away. We’re going to do what we can to help them.”
That’s a sentiment ingrained in Nunn, whose research background is in global health. Resources — including doctors — are often limited in those settings, so many things are led by nurses or community health workers. The model not only empowers non-physician health care workers to do more, Nunn said, but it creates an informed and prepared community that’s able to deliver care more efficiently. For example, a nurse-led STI screening process at Open Door Health adopts standing orders — written protocols that authorize certain health providers, like nurses and medical assistants, to complete certain clinical tasks without having to first obtain a physician order.
By using this model, the clinic has been able to keep costs low and dramatically scale up STI screening — a crucial need, as the positivity rate for STI services at Open Door Health is 25%, five times the national average.
Clinical Nurse Manager Leigh Hubbard oversees the STI screening program and said that within nine months of offering walk-in testing services, they’ve tested, treated and educated more than 1,000 people, preventing further community spread of infections.
During one screening encounter, Hubbard said she spoke with a patient who was at high risk for contracting HIV about taking PrEP. He was hesitant because he was uninsured, and out-of-pocket PrEP can cost $1,000 per month. Hubbard worked with a patient advocacy program to get his medication costs covered and provided him with information about the health insurance exchange; when the patient returned for a follow-up appointment, he had obtained coverage and had his first physical in five years. Since then, he’s continued to return to the clinic for vaccinations, screenings and continued PrEP therapy.
“This is what’s possible when you open doors for people, when you’re real with them, educate them and help them overcome their fears and any barriers that are keeping them from getting care,” Hubbard said. “And it all started with an STI test.”
Whether it’s how to implement health promotion programs to scale or how to most efficiently reduce infection rates among vulnerable populations, Nunn and Chan have spent decades studying pressing health issues in their scholarship and have, in turn, applied lessons learned from their studies to actual clinical practice. It’s a perfect illustration of the impact that research can have on community health.
“What we do at Open Door Health is public health in action. It’s policy in action. It’s our research delivered,” Chan said, “how it’s meant to be.”
A true impact on patients in Rhode Island
Study after study has shown that LGBTQ+ individuals often face barriers to accessing critical health services, and as a result can experience worse health outcomes. Stigma, judgement and discrimination impact the quality of care an LGBTQ+ patient receives — that is, if they aren’t outright denied care because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.
Unfortunately, that’s something Crooks has witnessed many times.
“I’ve had friends whose doctors wouldn’t prescribe them PrEP,” Crooks said, “because they either didn’t know about it, or they didn’t agree with it. And that’s not a doctor’s place, to decide that you don’t get to be on PrEP because they don’t agree with your lifestyle. Open Door Health is not like that at all.”
To address some of the health concerns that can arise from poor treatment — like mental health issues or substance abuse — the team at Open Door Health will never pass judgement on or withhold treatment from a patient for making decisions that they deem right for their own bodies, said Mary Beth Dromgoole, a nurse practitioner at the clinic who specializes in gender-affirming care.
Recognizing that gender-affirming care may look different for everyone, the clinic provides services that range from medical affirmation with hormones and referrals to surgical services to social support and obtaining new, revised legal documents like birth certificates and driver’s licenses.
“There's such vulnerability involved in these visits,” Dromgoole said. “Patients are often disclosing thoughts or feelings or truths that they have never spoken aloud before.”
Approaching those visits with warmth, knowledge and intentionality creates a clinical environment that aims to be truly inclusive — something that was sorely missing from the LGBTQ+ community in Rhode Island, patients and providers say. While Dromgoole expected to hear members of the community expressing that need, she said she was surprised to find that “all patients — even some of our patients of tremendous socioeconomic privilege — describe a sense that they are being ‘heard’ or ‘seen’ for the first time.”
For Crooks, that’s exactly why it’s so crucial that options like Open Door Health exist within all communities. Without that visibility and representation, he said, it’s difficult to know where to go or what to do when health questions arise.
“It’s much more inclusive now, but growing up, I never saw doctors talking to their patients about gender-affirming care or sexual encounters with people of the same sex or PrEP,” he said. “There can be an element of guilt or shame, or feeling like you’re in the wrong because you’re not seeing yourself represented. But you’re not. You still deserve care.”
Elizabeth Samuels, an assistant professor at the Warren Alpert Medical School, and medical student Aneeqah Naeem argued for federal action supporting harm reduction centers such as those authorized in Rhode Island.
Adriel Barrios-Anderson, who served as a student orator upon earning his bachelor’s degree from Brown in 2017, hopes to inspire newly minted M.D.s to feel confident about embracing the uncertainty of the future.